Interval Estimation for Robust Versions of Lorenz Curve IntegratingEmpirical Likelihood Framework With Influence Functions.
Abstract
Real-world data often pose significant challenges for statistical inference due to issues like outliers,
violation of classical assumptions, and inherent heterogeneity. Traditional parametric methods,
heavily reliant on assumptions such as normality and homoscedasticity, frequently yield unreliable
results when applied to skewed distributions, exemplified by income data with extremely high earners.
Empirical likelihood methods have gained prominence to overcome these limitations as they reduce
dependence on strict distributional assumptions. Further robustness is achieved by incorporating
influence functions into empirical likelihood frameworks, explicitly quantifying estimator sensitivity
to data contamination, and improving inference reliability. The Lorenz curve is a crucial economic
measure of income and wealth disparity, but is sensitive to skewness and outliers. This study introduces
robust quantile-based estimators for the Lorenz curve by integrating empirical likelihood and influence
function methodologies. Confidence intervals are constructed through empirical likelihood optimization
using a Lagrange multiplier framework and are evaluated against three bootstrap methods. Extensive
simulations reflecting realistic income distributions demonstrate that the influence function-based
empirical likelihood method significantly outperforms traditional empirical likelihood and other
statistical approaches. Its superior robustness arises primarily from effectively mitigating the distortive
effects of extreme observations. Consequently, this approach ensures reliable inference even under
challenging real-world conditions characterized by data abnormalities. Nevertheless, the proposed
methods present limitations, notably computational complexity and sensitivity to the assumptions
underlying influence functions. Future research should expand its application across socioeconomic
contexts, improve computational efficiency, and deepen theoretical and empirical exploration. This
framework equips researchers and policymakers with precise tools to measure and analyze income inequality.
Keywords:
Empirical likelihood, Influence function, Lagrange multiplier approach, Lorenz curve, Quantile inequality measuresReferences
- [1] [Kampke(2012)] Kämpke, T and Radermacher, FJ (2012) Lorenz curves history, state and some recent results.
- [2] [Athur(1988)] ART B. OWEN (1988) Empirical likelihood ratio confidence intervals for a single functional, Biometrika, Biometrika,
- [3] vol. 75, no. 2, pp. 237–249.
- [4] [Athur(1990)] ART B. OWEN (1990) Empirical likelihood ratio confidence regions, The annals of statistics, vol. 18, no. 1, pp.
- [5] –120.
- [6] [Lorenz(1905)] Lorenz, Max O (1905) Methods of measuring the concentration of wealth, Publications of the American statistical
- [7] association, vol. 9, no. 70, pp. 209–219.
- [8] [Joshep(2014)] Joseph L Gastwirth (2014) Median-based measures of inequality: Reassessing the increase in income inequality in
- [9] the US and Sweden, Statistical Journal of the IAOS, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 311–320.
- [10] [Thomas(2010)] Thomas Kampke (2010) The use of mean values vs. medians in inequality analysis, Journal of economic and social
- [11] measurement, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 43.
- [12] [Prendergast(2016)] Prendergast, Luke A and Staudte, Robert G (2016) Quantile versions of the Lorenz curve.
- [13] [Cowell(2002)] Cowell, Frank A and Victoria-Feser, Maria-Pia (2002) Welfare rankings in the presence of contaminated data,
- [14] Econometrica, vol. 70, no. 3, pp. 1221–1233.
- [15] [Gastwirth(1971)] Gastwirth, Joseph L (1971) A general definition of the Lorenz curve, Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric
- [16] Society, pp. 1037–1039.
- [17] [Prisner(2009)] Prisner, Erich (2009) Income distribution, Lorenz curve, and Gini index: a complex calculus project for the classroom,
- [18] Franklin College, Switzerland.
- [19] [Gastwirth(1972)] Gastwirth, Joseph L (1972) The estimation of the Lorenz curve and Gini index, The review of economics and
- [20] statistics, pp. 306–316.
- [21] [Lubrano(2017)] Lubrano, Michel (2017) The econometrics of inequality and poverty Chapter 4: Lorenz curves, the Gini coefficient
- [22] and parametric distributions.
- [23] [Qin(2013)] Qin, Gengsheng and Yang, Baoying and Belinga-Hall, Nelly E (2013) Empirical likelihood-based inferences for the
- [24] Lorenz curve, Annals of the Institute of Statistical Mathematics, vol. 65, pp. 1–21.
- [25] [Belz(2019)] Belz, Enora (2019) Estimating inequality measures from quantile data.
- [26] [Hampel(1971)] Hampel, Frank R (1971) A general qualitative definition of robustness, The annals of mathematical statistics, vol.
- [27] , no. 6, pp. 1887–1896.
- [28] [Yang(2012)] Yang, BY and Qin, GS and Belinga-Hill, Nelly E (2012) Non-parametric inferences for the generalized Lorenz curve,
- [29] Sci Sin Math, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 235–250.
- [30] [Kleiber(2008)] Kleiber, Christian (2008) "The Lorenz curve in economics and econometrics" in Advances on income inequality and
- [31] concentration measures , pp. 247–264.
- [32] [liu(2023)] Liu, Pangpang and Zhao, Yichuan (2023) A review of recent advances in empirical likelihood, Wiley Interdisciplinary
- [33] Reviews: Computational Statistics, vol. 15, no. 3, pp. e1599.
- [34] [Lomax(1954)] Lomax, Kenneth S (1954) Business failures: Another example of the analysis of failure data, Journal of the American
- [35] statistical association, vol. 49, no. 268, pp. 847–852.
- [36] [Lai(2006)] Lai, Chin-Diew and Murthy, DN and Xie, Min (2006) "Weibull distributions and their applications" in Springer
- [37] Handbooks, pp. 63–78.
- [38] [Torrent(1978)] Torrent, Roberto (1978) The log-normal distribution: A better fitness for the results of mechanical testing of
- [39] materials, Matériaux et Constructions, vol. 11, pp. 235–245.
- [40] [kleiber(2008)] Kleiber, Christian (2008) "A guide to the Dagum distributions" in Modeling income distributions and Lorenz curves,
- [41] pp. 97–117.
- [42] [shi(2020)] Shi, Yuyin and Liu, Bing and Qin, Gengsheng (2020) Influence function-based empirical likelihood and generalized
- [43] confidence intervals for the Lorenz curve, Statistical Methods & Applications, vol. 29, pp. 427–446.
- [44] [ratnasingam(2024)] Ratnasingam, Suthakaran and Wallace, Spencer and Amani, Imran and Romero, Jade (2024) Nonparametric
- [45] confidence intervals for generalized Lorenz curve using modified empirical likelihood, Computational Statistics, vol. 39, no. 6,
- [46] pp. 3073–3090.
- [47] [vejdani(2023)] Vejdani, Mahdiyeh and Roknabadi, Abdolhamid Rezaei and Fakoor, Vahid and Jomhoori, Sarah (2023) Empirical
- [48] Likelihood Confidence Intervals for Lorenz Curve with Length-Biased Data, Iranian Journal of Science, vol. 47, no. 5, pp.
- [49] –1631.